1. What issues involving U.S. interests were raised in the case study you read?
An important issue from the article was al-Qaeda, and the Obama Administration's attacks on al-Qaeda hideouts and bases. The issue with these attacks, however, is that according to a study by legal experts at Stanford and New York University, the majority of these attacks are actually killing Pakistani civilians, instead of militants. The report claims that over the past eight years, over 345 drone strikes have hit Pakistan's tribal areas, but less than 2% of the strike victims were known militants. However, the Obama Administration claims that civilian casualties are rare, and that the drone strikes have been a success.
2. Imagine that you could make U.S. foreign policy recommendations to the President; what would you say to explain your idea of National Interest and how it relates to this case? What goal would you recommend the President pursue in addressing the issues raised in the case you read?
I recommend that the Obama Administration stop the drone strikes. While I understand it seems like the safest way to go about taking out al-Qaeda bases, the rate of civilian casualties is simply too high to continue using them as a just strategy to take out Al-Qaeda. In all the drone strikes in the past eight years, little more than 98% of the deaths were civilian. Instead, we should send actual US militants into Pakistan on these operations. Under international law, nations at war must take great precautions to make sure that civilians are not killed. I think this is the best way to ensure the safety of Pakistani civilians.
Kt's Middle East Blog
Wednesday, May 6, 2015
Thursday, April 23, 2015
National Interest Breakdown
Of course all three categories of interests (security, economic, ideological) come into play in developing national interest, but which one of the three would you advocate as the most important basis for formulating foreign policy? Why?
While all three are very important, if I had to choose one, I think I would choose ideological. I think that ideological is the most important basis for formulating foreign policy because it can sort of fit into the other categories as well. It's easy to make money, but I think it's also important to look at how we're making that money. Are we making money via slave labor over seas? This is an important issue that falls under both economic and ideological. Ideology can also fit into security. If we build good relations with other countries, then we have a lesser chance of being attacked or invaded- and if we do get attacked or invaded, then we will have allies who will help us in our time of need.
While all three are very important, if I had to choose one, I think I would choose ideological. I think that ideological is the most important basis for formulating foreign policy because it can sort of fit into the other categories as well. It's easy to make money, but I think it's also important to look at how we're making that money. Are we making money via slave labor over seas? This is an important issue that falls under both economic and ideological. Ideology can also fit into security. If we build good relations with other countries, then we have a lesser chance of being attacked or invaded- and if we do get attacked or invaded, then we will have allies who will help us in our time of need.
Monday, April 20, 2015
Kingdom of Heaven Questions
1. What is Saladin's response to Balian's question of "What is Jerusalem worth?" What does his answer mean?
At first, Saladin says, "Nothing," but then after taking a few steps he turns around and says, "Everything." By this, I think it's possible that he means Jerusalem is really worth nothing, but people think that it is worth everything. Either that, or it could mean that Jerusalem is unimportant to him, but its very important to the people.
2. What is the difference between Arab/Arabian and a Muslim?
An Arab is someone who lives in the Arabian region, and a Muslim is someone who follows the Islam religion. You can have an Arab of any religion, Muslim, Christian, Jewish, what have you- and you could also have a Muslim who lives anywhere. There are Arab Muslims, American Muslims, European Muslims, etc.
3. What are the key issues in the film?
The biggest issue is obviously the war. They went to war for control of Jerusalem, and also they fought because the Templars wanted the Muslims dead. Another smaller issue is the conflict that can exist within one religion. Balian and the leper king had a different view than the Templars on Christianity and what God would want.
4.What do you think motivates the crusaders? Is it genuine faith or something else? If so, what? Why do you believe this?
I think it's a combination of wealth, and religion, that motivates the crusaders. The templars wanted to kill the Muslims, because God willed it. But, later on in the movie, Tiberious had said that he thought they were fighting for their faith, but then he realizes they were fighting about wealth, and so he left Jerusalem and didn't fight in the war.
5. What do you think Scott wants us to take away from the film? Why?
I think maybe he wanted the audience to walk away a little more educated about a chunk of history in Jerusalem, but also its possible that he wanted to portray how ridiculous it is that we are still fighting over this piece of land a thousand years later. The main protagonist, Balian, was all about protecting the people. His philosophy was that Jerusalem was not nearly as important as the people living inside Jerusalem, and I think that that's the message Scott is also trying to get across.
6. How are Christianity and Islam portrayed in the film? Provide examples.
The Christianity that the Templars believe in is sort of portrayed as barbaric. They are these "bad guys" who are motivated by killing Muslims. The Christianity that Balian believes in, is the Christianity that Christianity was supposed to be. It's about protecting the people, protecting all people, everyone's holy places were equally as important- he basically had all the same ideas Jesus did. He talks about all of this throughout the entire movie, but has a whole speech about it near the end of the movie, before the Muslims bust through the walls. The Muslims are portrayed as being very respectful, as it shows when they're throwing flower petals for the dead. Their respect is also shown when Saladin doesn't walk on the cross on the ground, and when he picks up the golden cross fixture that had fallen on the ground.
At first, Saladin says, "Nothing," but then after taking a few steps he turns around and says, "Everything." By this, I think it's possible that he means Jerusalem is really worth nothing, but people think that it is worth everything. Either that, or it could mean that Jerusalem is unimportant to him, but its very important to the people.
2. What is the difference between Arab/Arabian and a Muslim?
An Arab is someone who lives in the Arabian region, and a Muslim is someone who follows the Islam religion. You can have an Arab of any religion, Muslim, Christian, Jewish, what have you- and you could also have a Muslim who lives anywhere. There are Arab Muslims, American Muslims, European Muslims, etc.
3. What are the key issues in the film?
The biggest issue is obviously the war. They went to war for control of Jerusalem, and also they fought because the Templars wanted the Muslims dead. Another smaller issue is the conflict that can exist within one religion. Balian and the leper king had a different view than the Templars on Christianity and what God would want.
4.What do you think motivates the crusaders? Is it genuine faith or something else? If so, what? Why do you believe this?
I think it's a combination of wealth, and religion, that motivates the crusaders. The templars wanted to kill the Muslims, because God willed it. But, later on in the movie, Tiberious had said that he thought they were fighting for their faith, but then he realizes they were fighting about wealth, and so he left Jerusalem and didn't fight in the war.
5. What do you think Scott wants us to take away from the film? Why?
I think maybe he wanted the audience to walk away a little more educated about a chunk of history in Jerusalem, but also its possible that he wanted to portray how ridiculous it is that we are still fighting over this piece of land a thousand years later. The main protagonist, Balian, was all about protecting the people. His philosophy was that Jerusalem was not nearly as important as the people living inside Jerusalem, and I think that that's the message Scott is also trying to get across.
6. How are Christianity and Islam portrayed in the film? Provide examples.
The Christianity that the Templars believe in is sort of portrayed as barbaric. They are these "bad guys" who are motivated by killing Muslims. The Christianity that Balian believes in, is the Christianity that Christianity was supposed to be. It's about protecting the people, protecting all people, everyone's holy places were equally as important- he basically had all the same ideas Jesus did. He talks about all of this throughout the entire movie, but has a whole speech about it near the end of the movie, before the Muslims bust through the walls. The Muslims are portrayed as being very respectful, as it shows when they're throwing flower petals for the dead. Their respect is also shown when Saladin doesn't walk on the cross on the ground, and when he picks up the golden cross fixture that had fallen on the ground.
What Are My Intentions and What Do I Already Know?
What are your credit intentions (Quarter, Core, or Full)?
My intention is to get full credit for this class, or at least core credit. I can't remember exactly how much government credit I need, so that will dictate whether or not a do a project for full credit.
How do you define "Middle East"? Include region and culture, population, length of habitation, major geographic features and climate, and exerted influence by the United States (major events and when they happened).
The Middle East is a region that is partially in Europe, and partially in Asia, and is northeast of Africa. I think it has been inhabited for a long time, because it's so close to Africa, and Africa has been inhabited for a long time. It appears to be fairly hot there. The United States has an interest in the Middle East because of the oil in that region. They have also had an interest in that region because America has been concerned about WMDs and terrorism.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)